Hey thanks for popping to check out my blog and be sure to subscribe to my RSS feed. Thanks for visiting!
I read on TechCrunch this morning that Duncan Riley is against the new Pay-Per-Play audio ad idea (although he recommends it for his competitors) and I’d like to point out why he’s spot on with his assessment of the situation.
The Web started out as a silent affair and while I don’t believe in slavishly standing on ceremony, as it were, I do believe in respecting the ears and needs of your reader/viewer/listener and respecting the nature of the system and its current state of transformation.
Granted, the Web has now become a fully multi-media laden world and there are many advertisers successfully using audio, even compulsory-on-page-load audio in their ads. But, didn’t we agree a while back that the Web is not TV? TV is passive and we all accepted long ago that we watch what we get and the most control we have over it is to switch the channel, or mute it, or shut it off if we don’t like what we’re getting. Therefore, we don’t get pissed when a commercial comes on because we know that’s how it works.
But that’s not how the Web started, or how it works today. The Pay-Per-Play idea is old-school mass media trying to force the one-to-many model back down our throats and that’s not only irritating, it’s downright disrespectful.
The Web comes from a completely opposing side of the control spectrum where we have always had almost complete control over what we’re going to look at, or look for, and how we’re going to consume what we find. To suddenly and arbitrarily violate this agreement between Web consumers and information providers is a slap in the face to both parties and I suspect that’s why it’s so annoying for most people.
I know I will leave a site immediately if I can’t control the audio on the page, and apparently these Pay-Per-Play ads are set to fire off uncontrollably at 3 minute intervals the whole time you’re on a site.
From the Pay-Per-Play site:
The audio ad is only 5 seconds in length and a website visitor will only hear one 5 second advertisement per visit to any specific web page where the PPP code has been inserted. The visitor will only hear one audio ad for every 3 minutes they visit if they have already heard an audio ad on another page of the same website.
I just experienced the demo ad, and guess what? My speakers were turned way up (which I hadn’t realized) and the sub-woofer was turned up for a CD I was listening to recently and that Taco Bell ad blared horribly for 5 seconds.
It was so short a time that even if there was a pause button, I would have spent the whole time looking for it and attempting to click it. Ouch. Truly an ugly experience and not one I care to repeat, let alone every 3 minutes while I’m moving from page to page on someone’s site.
I think a good solution for advertisers and readers is to offer video, or audio content either paused with a play button, or muted with an option to unmute and start at the beginning, as I’ve seen some interstitial ads do recently. That way we can have the audio-visual experience, or not, as we’re so inclined.
Will you put these ads on your web site?
Loading ...
Recent Comments